Health benefits

Will universal medical insurance eventually strangle the ESIC scheme?

| FEBRUARY 25, 2016, 03:05 AM IST
The core responsibility of the Employees State Insurance Corporation is to provide medical benefits to those who cannot either afford to avail of it through established channels or buy insurance cover in the market, and by extending benefits to over 10,000
construction workers, ESIC has shown that it has not lost sight of its beliefs.
Goa has a fairly large construction industry employing workers from different parts of the country. Most of these workers are employed on daily wages and in the normal course they would have been left to fend for themselves as they do not fit into the rules prescribed by the ESIC. The old rules stipulated that any worker earning less than Rs 15,000 in registered establishments would be covered under the ESIC scheme which
meant that those working in offices of construction companies could avail of this benefit while those at the site, who were more vulnerable to accidents and illness, were left out. This
has now changed with ESIC extending
benefits to constructions
workers in the field. In Goa alone
around 10,000 workers have been
brought under the scheme and they
will now receive cash and medical
benefits.
The idea of providing medical
cover to industrial workers was
first brought to the table in 1923. B
N Adarkar was appointed to give shape to the idea but it was
only in 1952 that this facility was established through an Act. It
was initially intended for workers in factories and companies
but was later extended to any establishment having 10 workers
or more.
At present, ESIC has a network of 1,403 dispensaries, 1,678
panel clinics, 150 hospitals and 42 hospital annexes with over
22,335 beds. It caters to over seven crore beneficiaries of which
seven lakh are in Goa. In the field of healthcare it forms the
third arm along with the private and public sector. ESIC serves
a purpose in as much as it forces employees and employers to
contribute towards healthcare and in that sense it is almost
like medical insurance. However, with free medical benefits
being extended by government hospitals and state governments
embracing universal mediclaim, a question mark hangs
over the future of ESIC.
In the last decade or so healthcare has under gone a sea of
change. Easy availability of medical insurance and growth of
the private sector has increased the number of options available
to patients. However, for those earning less than Rs 15,000
per month there is only one option – ESIC. Having contributed
to the scheme beneficiaries have to avail of these services or
forfeit money contributed. What goes in favour of the scheme
is the number of beneficiaries. In 2015-16 over 7,000 workers
claimed Rs 159 lakh as sickness benefit while Rs 94.74 lakh
was claimed by 965 women as maternity benefits. This is just a
small part of the total benefits paid out to workers under various
categories of claims and this alone would justify the existence
of ESIC scheme. However, only a cost-benefit study will
give a clear picture of whether the money is being well spent or
used to duplicate services already available in the public and
private sectors. The general rule is that services once extended
cannot be withdrawn without causing unrest. One does not
want to leave workers in the lurch, but a review would throw
up suggestions on how to build a cost-effective yet robust system
for delivering healthcare for all.
Share this