SAVIO CORREIA
The National Green Tribunal Act is considered as a classic case of judge-driven reform. It was the plethora of judgments of our Supreme Court and High Courts on the need for a specialized environmental court that prompted Parliament to enact this landmark legislation in 2010.
Besides, constitution of a specialized environmental court was in keeping with India’s commitments in international conventions such as Stockholm Declaration 1972 and Rio Declaration 1992. Principle 10 of the Rio Declaration speaks of providing every individual with effective access to judicial and administrative proceedings in environmental cases, including redress and remedy.
Under the NGT Act, the powers of a civil court to entertain environmental matters were vested in the National Green Tribunal. In other words, the NGT Act expressly ousts the jurisdiction of civil courts to entertain cases relating to the environment. Therefore, for example, a tribal litigant from Sanguem who could have otherwise approached the civil court at Sanguem or Quepem now has to file his case to protect the environment in the NGT bench at Pune. Invariably, this violates his right to easy accessibility to justice.
Circuit benches of NGT are already operating at Shimla, Shillong and Jodhpur.
A cogent reason for having a circuit bench in Goa is admitted by the Government itself. Apparently, 70% of the cases in the NGT Bench at Pune emanate from Goa. In this backdrop, in a lighter vein, the NGT Western Zone Bench ought to have been located in Goa with a circuit bench at Pune!
Another important fact that was missed out in the Assembly debate was the 2017 judgment of our High Court in Goa Foundation & others v/s Ministry of Environment & Forests in PILs challenging the Central Government order bringing Goa under jurisdiction of NGT’s Principal Bench at New Delhi.
Speaking for the Court, Justice Gautam Patel opined (at para 48):
“We say this because, though we cannot command it, we can most emphatically commend it: that both the State Government and the MOEF must immediately take up with all seriousness the proposal to establish a Circuit Bench in Goa.”
And then, at para 47, while discussing the need to protect Goa’s ecology and the large number of Goa-related cases in the NGT, the Court ended the paragraph with the words: “For this is something none can deny: this is a land truly worth fighting for.”
Access to justice is one of the important elements of good governance.
Mere apprehensions of a NGT circuit bench likely to be misused by some sections to blackmail others etc cannot be a valid reason not to have one in Goa.
Besides the convenience of the litigants and their advocates, having a circuit bench in Goa would also save the Government precious public funds spent in legal and conveyance
costs of sending advocates and officials to Pune and New Delhi.
