SUNDAY, 22 NOVEMBER 2026

Setback for MPT’s coal expansion plans as expert committee declines clearance

Ashley do Rosario   

PANAJI   

In a setback to the Mormugao Port Trust, the Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC) of the Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change (MoEF&CC) has refused to grant it the all important Environmental and CRZ clearances for the expansion plan to spike volumes of coal it handles.   

The EAC, which held its 42nd meeting over three days on July 10, 11 and 12, decided to defer the grant of EC and CRZ clearance primarily because MPT failed to address issues raised at the public hearing conducted by the Goa State Pollution Control Board on April 27 and from May 2-4, 2017.   

The EAC said the project proponent (MPT) and its accredited consultant M/s WAPCOS Limited have not addressed some of the issues raised at the 2017 public hearings held at the Tilak Maidan in Vasco while deciding to defer its nod for the EC and CRZ clearance.   

Health impact due to coal handling, tree plantation, protection of humpback dolphins, impact of dredging on marine ecology, sustainable use of dredged material and detailed carrying capacity study were listed by the EAC in the minutes of the meeting which were raised in the public hearing and left unaddressed by MPT and M/s WAPCOS Limited.   

In an olive branch held out to MPT, however, the EAC said and recorded in the minutes: “The proposal shall be reconsidered after the above details are addressed and submitted.”   

The proposal to carry out capital dredging of up to 12 million cubic metres of weathered rock besides maintenance dredging to deepen the approach channel for Capesize vessels had secured the 

nod of the MoEFCC in 2016 but successfully challenged by the Goenchea Ramponkarancho Ekvott (GRE) and others before the National Green Tribunal.   

In September 2016 the NGT quashed the EC granted by the MoEFCC holding that its decision to exempt public hearing mandated by the Environment Impact Assessment notification of 2006 was a violation of the law. The NGT also reverted the issue back to the MoEFCC’s expert appraisal committee for compliance of the statute that required holding an EIA public hearing.   

Accordingly, terms of reference were determined by the EAC and the Goa State Pollution Control Board was given the mandate to conduct the public hearing. Hundreds of Goa’s greens, civil society organisations and politicians participated in the marathon public hearing held at Vasco’s Tilak maidan.   

Strangely, the MPT and the consultant it hired -- M/s WAPCOS Limited -- failed to document and address the issues raised at this public hearing in the papers it presented to the MoEFCC to apply afresh for the EC and CRZ clearance.   

It only said that issues raised at the public hearing have been addressed in ‘volume II’ of the EIA report but the same was not uploaded on MoEFCC site nor was a hard copy presented to the EAC.   

Interestingly, the Goa Coastal Zone Management Authority (GCZMA), meanwhile has “recommended” to the MoEFCC the grant of the CRZ clearances for the project.   

The capital and maintenance dredging project has been estimated to cost Rs 289 crores and MPT proposed to execute it on a public-private participation (PPP) model.  

SHARE ON

PEOPLE’S POWER PREVAILS

Coastal plan presentation in Margao ends in fiasco Hundreds say no to controversial plan ,Cabral booed, heckled; leaves venue with police protection , Presentation ends abruptly amid protests & demands for scrapping CZMP

The Goan Network
Published Jul 28, 2019, 2:48 AM IST
SHARE ON

the goan I networkMARGAOGovernment’s Coastal Zone Management Plan (CZMP) presentation at the Ravindra Bhavan, Margao ended in a big fiasco as the department of environment tried to bulldoze its way with the presentation amidst uproarious scenes as hundreds of people with one voice outrightly rejected the controversial plan.Environment Minister Nilesh Cabral had to be escorted out of the Ravindra Bhavan by a strong police force led by DySP Serafino Dias as agitated people…

READ MORE

Keep Reading — More from GOA NEWS

2 more related stories queued · tap to continue reading

Home HOME News GOA NEWS Global GLOBAL GOENKAR Search SEARCH