the goan I network
OLD GOA
The opponents of the Bainguinim waste treatment plant came well-prepared and put forth their points with justification as they opined that the site was not suitable as it is a water harvesting area, close to habitation, close to world heritage sites, etc.
Speaking at a mammoth 10 hour public hearing on the setting up of a solid waste management plant at Bainguinim, on Sunday, Silverio Dias from Milroc-Kadamba stated that the site is a strong water catchment area with the existence of a spring called St Antonio spring close by.
“It is close to UNESCO heritage sites with cluster of churches and convents. Thousands of people visit Old Goa,” he stated while adding that there are human settlements all around. “The total number of flats in the vicinity of the site is 1475 units. There is a mutt nearby as well as a school with over 800 students,” he stated.
“A buffer zone of 500 metres has to be maintained around the plant but that has not been maintained and if the guidelines of Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) are considered, then legally the plant cannot be set up there,” he stated.
“Clean environment is fundamental right of a citizen and it is the duty of the local bodies as well as the government to ensure safe public health,” Dias informed while adding that setting up the plant will violate these rights enshrined under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution.
NIO scientist Arwind Saran pointed out that the draft EIA report is full of mistakes. “The data collection is done by taking into account only one season when it is mandated that the data should be collected for three seasons for a comprehensive report,” Saran stated and added that if environment clearance is granted on this report then it is an ill-conceived method and process bypassing CPCB guidelines.
“This area is rich in groundwater. Has there been any measurement done for groundwater with technology like ground penetration radar wherein one can measure ground water layers and its recharge and discharge mechanisms, not only for one season but all seasons in a year,” he questioned.
“There is no measurement of arsenic and mercury listed in the table of the EIA report,” he further pointed out.
“All residents at Bainguinim are heavily dependent on borewell water and this water will be contaminated if the plant comes up thereby putting the life of the people in danger,” he added.
Various other speakers also spoke on the hazardous gases that will be emanated at the plant like nitroxide, methane, hydrogen sulphide and others which will put the lives of the residents at risk if any explosion occurs at the
plant.
Others also came down heavily on the TCP department for giving licences for residential projects to come up within the vicinity of the plant site.
“When we bought a flat over here, the builder clearly stated that there won’t be any waste treatment plant coming up,” Sandip Naik stated while adding that not a single board was also displayed at the plant site that the land has been earmarked for a garbage treatment plant.
“How were we supposed to know that a garbage treatment plant was planned here?” Naik questioned while stating that he would have never invested his hard earned money in buying a flat there. He further demanded that if the government is going ahead with the plant, then it should relocate everybody at the current value of their properties. “Can the government do that first?” he posed.
Some other speakers also stated that animals like monitor lizard are not mentioned in the report as well as the national bird peacock.
“There is also no mention of the Dr Salim Ali bird sanctuary, Carambolim lake, Batim lake and various other bodies within the vicinity of the plant site,” the speakers pointed out.
A local Bernadette Fernandes stated that they had opposed granting of licences to residential projects in the vicinity of the plant site but the panchayat said that the TCP is granting licences. She further stated that a decentralized system of garbage management is needed wherein garbage plants have to be set up within the villages and the municipalities.
‘Set up IT Park at Bainguinim instead’
OLD GOA : Even as Old Goa locals opposed the setting up of solid waste management plant at Bainguinim, they have suggested that the government instead set up IT industry in the area.
Speaking at the public hearing, former Se Old Goa sarpanch Prakash Amonkar suggested that IT industry can be set up at the site which will help in stopping the brain drain from Goa.
Another speaker Amber Amonkar also proposed that IT Park should be set up in Bainguinim. “The government can set up IT Park at the Bainguinim site,” Amonkar suggested.
