MONDAY, 23 NOVEMBER 2026
Ticker

Form society or pay treble house tax: Calangute p'yat faces legal challenge

Writ petition questions legality of treble tax penalty, Rs 15,000 transfer fee and linking ownership records to housing societies

MAPUSA

Can a village panchayat penalise an individual flat owner for the failure of an entire housing complex to form a society? And can it refuse to update ownership details in its house tax records until residents comply with such a directive?

These are among the larger questions raised in a writ petition filed before the Bombay High Court at Goa challenging a series of decisions taken by the Calangute Village Panchayat, including its threat to triple house tax for complexes that fail to register housing societies.

Petitioner Dr Benjamin Braganca has questioned what he describes as an arbitrary attempt by the panchayat to link three otherwise separate matters – transfer of house tax records, formation of housing societies and collection of house tax – placing individual flat owners at the receiving end of decisions that may be beyond their control.

At the centre of the dispute is a public notice issued on July 14, directing residents of flats, housing societies and residential and commercial complexes to form and register societies under the Goa Co-operative Societies Act, 2001, within a month, failing which the panchayat would impose three times the existing house tax. The notice was issued pursuant to a resolution adopted on June 29.

The petitioner argues that society formation is a collective exercise requiring the cooperation of multiple flat owners and cannot be forced upon an individual resident.

Citing his own complex, Kamat Holiday Homes at Gauravaddo, he points out that it has around 120 flats, several of whose owners reside overseas. Securing the consent and participation of at least 61 owners, he contends, is hardly within the control of one flat owner.

The dispute also exposes another contentious issue – the use of house tax records as a condition for enforcing the society-formation directive.

Braganca had approached the panchayat on August 3 seeking transfer of house tax records of his flat into his name, following its purchase through a registered sale deed in 2018. Despite having paid house tax up to date, the panchayat allegedly refused to process the application unless a society was formed and its NOC produced.

The petitioner maintains that recording a change in ownership is an administrative exercise and cannot be made conditional upon the formation of a society, whose primary purpose is to manage the common affairs of a residential complex.

Adding another dimension to the dispute, the petition questions the alleged Rs 15,000 fee charged for transferring house tax records, claiming that the amount has no legal backing and that there is no prescribed provision authorising such an exorbitant charge.

The petitioner has sought the quashing of the July 14 notice, a direction to update his house tax records and intervention by the Directorate of Panchayats to frame uniform guidelines for transfer of house tax records and prescribe a ceiling on the fees charged by panchayats.

The petition raises questions of arbitrariness, equality before law and administrative fairness under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution.

The matter came up before the High Court last week and is listed for December 9.

The court has clarified that the pendency of the petition will not prevent the Calangute panchayat from taking a decision in the meantime on whether to grant the transfer of house tax records.



 


SHARE ON

Builder denies pressurizing school, alleges compound wall encroachment

The Goan Network
Published Nov 22, 2026, 11:23 PM IST
SHARE ON

MAPUSABuilder Mario Fernandes has refuted allegations that he pressurized the management of St Mary’s Primary School to demolish its compound wall and playground to provide access to his commercial project.“What they have said is completely false. In fact, their compound wall is completely illegal. They have encroached 100 metres on the road,” Fernandes claimed.Denying allegations that his eight-plus-storey commercial complex was coming up on a landlocked property without…

READ MORE

Keep Reading — More from GOA NEWS

1 more related stories queued · tap to continue reading

Home HOME News GOA NEWS Global GLOBAL GOENKAR Search SEARCH