PANAJI
The High Court of Bombay at Goa quashed a 2022 order directing demolition of a house in Dabolim while pulling up the Deputy Collector for failing to examine whether the construction existed before the Goa Land (Prohibition on Construction) Act, 1995 came into force.
In its order, the Bench of Justice S G Chapalgaonkar observed that petitioner Shanti Passi had specifically denied raising any unauthorised construction after 1991, but the Deputy Collector (Mormugao) had not considered or adjudicated this plea. It had ordered the removal of the alleged unauthorised construction on September 27, 2022.
The petitioner had submitted that her family owned the house property for over 40 years and had paid house tax to the Village Panchayat. She also placed before the Deputy Collector a tax receipt dating back to 1991 in the name of her mother-in-law, Dulari Passi, to establish the property’s existence before the 1995 Act came into force.
The High Court observed that Section 4 of the Act prohibits construction on land belonging to the government, local authorities or Communidades without written permission. However, it noted, “any construction which is in existence prior to commencement of aforesaid Act cannot be subject matter of proceedings for action under Act of 1995.” “It was, therefore, necessary on part of Deputy Collector to decide whether construction raised by Petitioner was in existence before commencement of Act and pass further orders,” the court held.
The matter has been remanded for fresh consideration with the parties to appear before the Deputy Collector on December 8, and the officer to pronounce orders within four months.
