File photo of a sample pipe to be used for water diversion at the fabrication site near Nersa village near Khanapur.
BELAGAVI
Karnataka has termed the Centre’s objections to processing statutory clearances for the Kalasa-Bhandura water diversion project in the Mhadei basin “frivolous” and legally unsustainable.
In a legal submission, Karnataka’s Supreme Court Senior Counsel Mohan Katarki argued that neither Goa’s pending appeal against the Mhadei Water Disputes Tribunal (MWDT) award nor a March 29, 2023 order by Goa’s Wildlife Warden can prevent implementation of the notified award.
The Centre has reportedly withheld clearances citing the pending Supreme Court case and the Wildlife Warden’s order under Section 29 of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972.
Refuting the first objection, Katarki said the Supreme Court has not stayed the tribunal award. Citing Order XLI, Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), he argued that filing an appeal does not automatically stay an order or award.
Katarki termed the Wildlife Warden’s order prima facie unconstitutional, arguing that it exceeded Goa’s territorial jurisdiction and was directed against the Karnataka Government, not the Centre. He said the Centre must direct Goa to withdraw it under Section 62B of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, read with Article 256 of the Constitution.
The dispute concerns Karnataka’s plans to divert water from the Mahadayi basin through the Kalasa and Bhandura nala schemes to the Malaprabha basin to meet drinking water needs in drought-prone North Karnataka.
Goa opposes the diversion on environmental and water-sharing grounds, while Karnataka maintains it is essential for the region. The latest submission challenges the Centre’s position and seeks clearances for the long-delayed project.
