PANAJI
Three consecutive terms in power might have given the BJP a recognisable political identity in Goa, but the latest Prudent survey suggests that longevity may now be turning into an electoral liability.
Nearly two-thirds of respondents want a change of government, while more than half rate the BJP-led dispensation's performance poorly, clearly indicating that the 2027 Assembly contest could test the limits of the ruling alliance's staying power.
The survey titled 'Mood of the State,' projects 16-18 seats for the BJP-MGP alliance against 14-15 for a Congress-led alliance -- a potentially hung Assembly. With 26 per cent of the projected vote share still undecided, the electoral picture remains fluid.
The findings present a difficult picture for the BJP, which has been in power since 2012. While 21.8 per cent rated the government's performance as 'very good' and an equal percentage as 'good,' 29.1 percent rated it 'bad' and 27.3 per cent 'worst.' Together, 56.4 per cent expressed dissatisfaction.
Prof Nilesh Borde, associated with the survey exercise for 15 years, said the findings reflected widespread public discontent. "There is an overall Goa-level discontent in the minds of the people against the government, probably because it has been there for the last three terms," he said.
The appetite for change, however, has not translated into a consolidated preference for an alternative. While 34.3 per cent favoured the existing BJP-MGP alliance, 22.8 per cent preferred a non-BJP alliance without defections. A Congress-led alliance received 12 per cent support, followed by Congress contesting alone at 11.8 per cent and a non-Congress, anti-BJP alliance at 11.6 per cent. Only 7.2 per cent preferred the BJP contesting alone, while the AAP received 0.3 per cent.
Borde said some committed BJP supporters were uncomfortable with leaders defecting from other parties and joining the BJP, suggesting that support for the party did not automatically translate into acceptance of its present political composition.
Sawant remains
BJP's strongest face
The leadership findings revealed an interesting contradiction wherein Chief Minister Pramod Sawant emerged as the preferred choice in one assessment at 33.5 per cent, ex-CM and sitting Minister Digambar Kamat stood second at 24.7 per cent and any non-BJP alliance leader at 23.9 per cent. Minister Vishwajit Rane received 9.6 per cent and his MLA wife Deviya Rane 4.4 per cent.
However, when respondents were asked who should become the next CM, 41.5 per cent preferred any non-BJP alliance leader, against 24.1 percent for Sawant, 12.9 per cent for Rane and 10.5 per cent for Kamat.
"People believe that whoever they vote for, Sawant will still be the CM. There are still some who are hopeful that a non-BJP alliance will emerge. The BJP has a face, but there is no non-BJP face," he said.
Ruling alliance
faces seat losses
The BJP-MGP alliance is projected to secure 16-18 seats with a 38 per cent vote share, compared with the BJP's largest 20 seats and 33.7 per cent vote share in 2022. The Congress-led alliance is projected at 14-15 seats with 29 per cent.
The AAP could win zero or one seat, with its projected vote share falling to 0.5 per cent from 6.8 per cent in 2022. The Revolutionary Goans Party, currently in the news over internal conflicts, is also projected at 0.5 per cent, down from around 10 per cent achieved in 2022 polls. Other parties could secure four to six seats.
The constituency assessment classified 15 constituencies, accounting for 45 per cent of the government's seats, as unsafe, 10 as 50-50 and eight as safe. Of the BJP's 28 seats, only seven were classified as safe. One of the MGP's two seats was safe, while none of the Independents supporting the government fell in that category.
Welfare schemes
no guarantee
Despite dissatisfaction with governance, 56.5 per cent said welfare schemes were a reason to re-elect the government, while 43.6 percent disagreed. Borde cautioned that beneficiaries could appreciate government schemes without necessarily voting for the BJP.
Difficulty accessing government offices topped the list of election concerns, cited by 77.5 per cent, followed by rising prices and concerns over water, identity and demography at 75 per cent each. Development figured at 57.5 per cent, land conversion under Section 39A at 47.5 per cent, corruption at 42.5 per cent and unemployment at 37.5 per cent.
Mega projects, defections and garbage management received 22.5, 20 and 10 percent respectively.
The findings also pointed to voters viewing their MLAs as intermediaries for accessing government services. Personal benefits mattered to 70 per cent while choosing a candidate, followed by candidate qualities at 65 per cent, past performance at 52.5 per cent and financial assistance at 50 per cent. Party affiliation mattered to 42.5 per cent.
As many as 95 per cent expected their MLA to help get work done in government offices, 75 per cent expected financial or personal assistance and 62.5 per cent expected constituency development. Only 7.4 per cent expected their representative to raise local issues in the Assembly.
"The takeaway is that without an MLA, the work does not get done. This is the situation with government offices," Borde said.
Poor performance emerged as the most undesirable candidate quality, cited by 100 per cent, followed by criminal antecedents at 91.1 per cent and frequent party changes at 54.1 per cent. Corruption scored 21.8 percent.
The survey found that 53.1 per cent rated their sitting MLA's performance as good or very good, against 47 per cent who rated it bad or very bad. On the best-performing government over the last four terms, the Congress-led dispensation received 39.8 per cent, narrowly ahead of the BJP-led government at 37.3 per cent, while 22.9 per cent favoured other governments.
