Margao Municipal Council has failed to learn lessons from the past and continues to experiment on garbage management. From the expensive fire-fighting enzymes which were flown in to fight the recent Sonsodo fire, to the Komex Industries experiment used to bio-remediate Sonsodo and the gamble with Black Hole technology, all have failed miserably. Now MMC has given its nod to Thermophillic Biomethanation container-based garbage treatment plants.
The civic body has once again hurried into a decision of introducing new technology unknown to Goa, without proper assessment. The trial and error methods not only reflect the callousness with which the MMC is approaching the issue, but also shows complete mismanagement of finances.
The Thermophillic Biomethanation process is given the nod, but on what basis? No doubt there are advantages on one side and on paper the new technology appears good. It can treat up to 20 tonnes of mixed waste every day, which means the civic body will be relieved of its responsibility of disposing segregated waste, an area they have failed miserably. The plant can be set up in an area as small as 500 sq mts. And to top it all, the plant can convert the mixed waste into methane which can be used as fuel.
But has the MMC studied the disadvantages? The technology may be used in Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s constituency of Varanasi and in other areas like Sholapur, that doesn’t mean it can fit into a city like Margao. Plastics form a significant component of Goa’s garbage and this could be a major deterrent in its treatment and generation of methane. The new process involves treating unsegregated garbage at high temperatures, the impact of which on the environment will have to be studied. There are risks of high amounts of carbon dioxide and other toxic gases being released in the air, increasing the levels of pollution.
Goans have been very environment-sensitive and the government has faced flak on such issues earlier. MMC must allay environmental concerns of its people who are already shaken with the pollution it is currently facing. Further, this proposal also needs a go-ahead from the Goa State Pollution Control Board, the State Environment Ministry and even the Solid Waste Management department.
While the idea of setting up two Thermophillic Biomethanation container plants is taking shape, the city fathers have ignored the bigger issue at hand. The container plants cannot be installed at short notice since there are processes and clearances involved, leave alone the financial burden of Rs 4 crore that the civic body has to bear. In the interim there is garbage crisis looming over the city. Come August 9 and Fomento’s termination comes into effect. Time is ticking and the need of the hour is to have a Plan B for garbage treatment immediately rather than look at long-term options.
