FRIDAY, 20 NOVEMBER 2026

Survey sets off alarm bells for 3 ministers, shows several defectors on shaky ground

Prudent’s Mood of the State assessment places several sitting MLAs in ‘unsafe’ zone; alliances could prove decisive

Survey sets off alarm bells for 3 ministers, shows several defectors on shaky ground Prudent Media Editorial Director Pramod Acharya in conversation with Professor Nilesh Borde while unveiling the Mood of the State Survey on Thursday.


PANAJI

Three serving ministers in the Goa government face an uncertain electoral future, with Prudent's Mood of the State pre-poll survey placing them in the unsafe category, while several legislators who defected to the BJP are also staring at a difficult battle in the 2027 Assembly elections.

In contrast, Chief Minister Pramod Sawant appears to be on safe ground in his Sanquelim constituency, with the survey placing him in the safe category. BJP leaders and Ministers like Vishwajit Rane (Valpoi), Rohan Khaunte (Porvorim), Babush Monserrate (Panaji) and Digambar Kamat (Margao) have also been rated safe.

The survey has categorised ministers Subhash Shirodkar (Shiroda), Nilkanth Halarnkar (Thivim) and Ramesh Tawadkar (Canacona) as unsafe, indicating that their chances of retaining their constituencies could be under considerable pressure. Sankalp Amonkar, who was lately inducted into the Cabinet, was also placed in the unsafe category based on data collected before his elevation as a minister.

The findings are significant for the BJP-led government, which is completing its third consecutive term, with voter dissatisfaction over individual performance and a desire for a change of government emerging as common factors in several constituencies.

Explaining the methodology, Professor Nilesh Borde, who has been associated with the survey exercise for nearly 15 years, said the assessment was based on two parameters -- public perception of the sitting MLA's performance and whether voters wanted a change of government.

"If both conditions go against the MLA, the constituency is marked unsafe. If one condition is favourable, it becomes 50-50, and if both are favourable, the MLA is considered safe," Borde explained.

He said the expectations from legislators were particularly high as the BJP government was completing its third term, with ministers and those who had switched parties facing an even higher performance benchmark.


DEFECTORS FACE THE HEAT


The survey presents an uncomfortable picture for several legislators who defected to the BJP, with their political realignment seemingly failing to translate into favourable public perception.

Subhash Shirodkar, who switched from the Congress to the BJP and became a minister, is unsafe in Shiroda. Borde said people were unhappy with his performance and were also looking for a change in government. The political uncertainty over the MGP's claim to the constituency and references to former MLA Mahadev Naik have further complicated the electoral equation.

Sankalp Amonkar, who also switched from the Congress to the BJP, is unsafe in Mormugao. Borde clarified that the survey data was collected when Amonkar was still an MLA and before his elevation as a minister. Voters were dissatisfied with his individual performance and favoured a change of government.

In Mapusa, BJP MLA Joshua D'Souza is also categorised as unsafe, with voters reportedly unhappy with his performance. Borde pointed out that comparisons with his late father were also working against him.

Kedar Naik, who moved from the Congress to the BJP, is unsafe in Saligao, while Rodolfo Fernandes, another Congress defector, is unsafe in Santa Cruz. Rajesh Faldessai, who switched from the Congress to the BJP, is also placed in the unsafe category in Cumbarjua.

Borde described Faldessai's position as a "bloodbath", saying voters were unhappy with both his ground-level performance and the government.


BJP'S ELECTORAL CHALLENGES


Apart from defectors, several BJP legislators are facing anti-incumbency in their constituencies. Praveen Arlekar in Pernem, Nilkanth Halarnkar in Thivim and Subhash Shirodkar in Shiroda are among those marked unsafe.

The list also includes Chandrakant Shetye in Bicholim, Kedar Naik in Saligao and Premendra Shet in Mayem, though the latter is placed in the 50-50 category. Mauvin Godinho in Dabolim and Daji Salkar in Vasco are also in the 50-50 bracket.

In Dabolim, Borde highlighted growing concerns over demographic changes and Goan identity, besides dissatisfaction with the minister's performance.

However, the survey also identifies BJP leaders who remain comfortably positioned. Chief Minister Pramod Sawant is safe in Sanquelim, while Vishwajit Rane in Valpoi, Rohan Khaunte in Porvorim, Babush Monserrate in Panaji and Digambar Kamat in Margao are also in the safe category.

Borde said public perception of individual performance was particularly favourable towards Khaunte and Kamat. In Panaji, despite complaints over Smart City works, voters appeared satisfied with Monserrate's performance.


OPPN NOT IMMUNE TO ANTI-INCUMBENCY


The survey also suggests that Opposition legislators cannot take their electoral prospects for granted. RGP MLA Viresh Borkar is unsafe in St Andre, while AAP's Cruz Silva is unsafe in Velim. AAP MLA Venzy Viegas is in the 50-50 category in Benaulim.

Borde said Borkar's individual performance was not rated favourably and voters were also looking for a change of government. He felt an alliance with the Congress could significantly improve Borkar's chances, adding that contesting independently as RGP would leave him in a vulnerable position.

Goa Forward Party president Vijai Sardesai is also in the 50-50 category in Fatorda. Borde said voters were divided over his performance and the alliance uncertainty surrounding the party had also influenced their perception.

Leader of Opposition Yuri Alemao is similarly placed in the 50-50 category in Cuncolim, while Congress MLA Aleixo Reginaldo is in the same category in Curtorim.

The survey also flags uncertainty in Ponda, where there is no sitting MLA following the demise of Ravi Naik. Borde said the BJP would be in an unsafe position if it contested alone, but an understanding with the MGP and a consensus candidate could improve its chances.

The assessment places Assembly Speaker Ganesh Gaonkar in the unsafe category in Sanguem, adding to the list of prominent ruling-side legislators facing electoral uncertainty.


ALLIANCES COULD DECIDE OUTCOME


The findings point to a fragmented electoral landscape, with alliances potentially determining the outcome in several constituencies. Fatorda, St Andre and Ponda are among the seats where political understandings could substantially alter the contest.

The survey's 50-50 category also includes Jit Arolkar in Mandrem, Delilah Lobo in Siolim, Michael Lobo in Calangute, Carlos Ferreira in Aldona, Govind Gaude in Poriem, Nilesh Cabral in Curchorem and several others.

The larger message is that neither the ruling side nor the Opposition has a uniform electoral advantage. While individual performance remains a decisive factor, voters' preference for a change of government could make the coming election particularly challenging for incumbents.

The survey is a projection based on the data collected and not a prediction of the final election outcome. Its second phase is expected to examine party-wise vote share, major electoral issues and the possibility of who could form the next government if elections were held today.


SHARE ON

Massive blaze rips through four shacks at Calangute

The Goan Network
Published Nov 20, 2026, 12:19 AM IST
SHARE ON
Massive blaze rips through four shacks at Calangute

MAPUSAJust as the tourism season was gathering momentum, a major fire gutted four consecutive beach shacks near Hotel Park and Hotel Goan Heritage at Gauravaddo in Calangute on Thursday afternoon, causing losses estimated at nearly Rs 1 crore.The fire, which reportedly originated in the kitchen of one of the shacks, spread rapidly to the adjoining structures as strong winds swept across the beach. All four shacks were reduced to ashes within barely five minutes, a fire…

READ MORE

Keep Reading — More from GOA NEWS

1 more related stories queued · tap to continue reading

Home HOME News GOA NEWS Global GLOBAL GOENKAR Search SEARCH