PANAJI
Three proposals for the scientific handling and recovery of iron ore from existing dumps in Sanguem taluka have been deferred by the Goa State Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) after it found the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) reports submitted by the project proponents inadequate and lacking comprehensive details required to initiate the appraisal process.
The committee, which examined the proposals at its 301st meeting held on October 30, has directed the project proponents to submit comprehensive and revised EIA reports covering all relevant environmental aspects, impacts within a 10-km radius and proposed mitigation measures before the proposals can be considered further.
The three proposals pertain to the recovery of iron ore from Dump No. 1 spread across 25.80 hectares in Costi and Dudal villages, Dump No. 3 covering 1.15 hectares in Costi village and Dump No. 4 spread over 3.80 hectares, also in Costi village.
The Dump No 1 proposal, submitted by Goa Sponge and Power Ltd, covers land across several survey numbers in Costi and Dudal villages. The company’s representatives, along with its accredited EIA consultants, appeared before the committee to present the project. However, after examining the submission, SEAC observed that the EIA report was inadequate and not comprehensive enough to facilitate the appraisal process.
Similar deficiencies were flagged in the proposals submitted by Sarus Infrastructures Pvt Ltd for Dump No. 3 and Dump No. 4 in Costi village.
In all three cases, the committee sought revised EIA reports incorporating the environmental aspects and likely impacts of the proposed dump-handling activities within a 10-km radius, along with appropriate mitigation measures. The proposals have consequently been deferred for Additional Details Sought (ADS).
The committee's observations underline the need for a more comprehensive assessment of the environmental implications of recovering ore from existing dumps before the projects can move ahead in the environmental clearance process.
Meanwhile, another ore dump proposal concerning the handling of Dump No. 15 at Bandoli village in Dharbandora, spread over 19.01 hectares was recommended by SEAC for grant of EC, subject to stipulated general and specific conditions. The proposal was moved by KAI International Pvt Ltd.
