THURSDAY, 17 SEPTEMBER 2026

Being a Goan at a time of Hindutva-III

Goa is a commodity that is being traded by tourism industry, political establishment and parties as well as the right wing fundamentalist forces

It is heartening to see that most socio-political and economic  issues in Goa have become Goa-centric. 

This welcome change is a  Goa-centric modus vivendi on the horizon. A vigorous Goa-centrism that  we can notice around is indeed a fresh breathe of life in our society.  

Several Goans have recognized the wounds inflicted on Goa by our own  politicians, industrialists, builders, tourism lobby, religious  fundamentalists and their ilk.  

This has angered Goans and brought them on the streets. The  antagonism against the establishment is rising by the day. Every right  thinking Goan is worried about the loss of something precious and  beautiful. 

We are painfully aware that we are already living on borrowed  time and it is next to impossible if not difficult to put the clock  back. 

Without falling into cynicism, Goans have shown that they have  chosen modus vivendi to bring life to the dying Goa, Goan-ness and  Goans.  

The loss that we intensely feel is about the loss of form. It is a  sense that seems to say to Goa: ‘thou are not that’. 

With this denial of  the upanisadic ‘tat tvam asi’, thou are that, we seem to have  intuitively raised the Kantian question about the condition of  possibility of a loss that informs Goa, Goans and Goan-ness.  

The loss that informs Goans is a loss of the constitutive form that  makes Goa, Goans and Goan-ness what it is.

Hence, it becomes a loss of  ‘Goa, Goan-ness and Goans’ in a radical way. Goa, Goan-ness and Goans  have gradually become commodities for exchange, shattering the dreams of  all Goans.  

 Goa is a commodity that is being traded by tourism industry,  political establishment and parties as well as the right wing  fundamentalist forces. 

The politics of Hindutva promotes a  socio-economics. It sides the commoditization of Goa. It too seems to  aim to grab power and had over the natural and cultural resources to its  cronies.  

A surplus value (Marx) is sought in a surplus enjoyment (Lacan) and  is thought to add surplus meaning (Ricouer) to our life by letting Goa  happen to the tourists on the prowl. 

This is why we have to understand  the socio-political and economic conditions that made Goa’s decline  actual. 

The surplus value of land resulted in a sale of Goan land to the  highest bidder (non-Goan). 

Surplus enjoyment led to the forgetting of  inter-generational justice as several Goans sold their land without  thinking of the generations to come.  

All this was thought to add surplus meaning of life pushing several Goans out of Goa on the wings of Portuguese passport.  

Adding to these socio-economic losses, we have the politics of  hindutva that has injected suspicion, hate, division and anger among  people of Goa. We have landed into a complex condition of isolation. 

An  inter-subjective dialogue/ communication (Habermas’s Formula) might not  always help. But dialogue we must with all stake holders to save Goa,  Goans and Goan-ness.  

Here we are challenged to be ethical rather aesthetical and discern  critically the real interest for Goa and Goans rather than one that  pretends and masks as working in the interest of Goa and Goans. 

This is  why we have to opt for Goa-centric modus vivendi. 

Besides, we have to do  a self examination. Often the quest for surplus value, surplus  enjoyment and surplus meaning of life has led us to put Goa on sale.  

We have to understand how we fetishize life in Goa and address it.  Being a king is an effect of social network of relations between the  king and his subjects. 

Here fethistic mis-recognition leads to the  perception that being king is a natural property of their ruler and they  are subjects because he is king.  

Likewise, we Goans sometimes fetishize our life by opting for  surplus value, surplus enjoyment and surplus meaning of life. 

Some do it  by selling land other by abandoning Goan culture and even by falling  prey to seductions of hindutva.  

We have unfortunately de-goanized Goa in several ways in search of  surplus life. 

Hence, we need to resist the temptation and the seduction  of tourism industry, political establishment and the right wing agenda.  

Somewhere all these intersect and synergize the de-goanization of Goa.    

This means, we have to imagine new possibilities of being Goans at a  time of hindutva married to 

the reigning socio-economic and political  order.       

SHARE ON

Wangchuk’s recipe for public education

Educationist Wangchuk who inspired the character Phunshuk Wangdu in 3 Idiots, on being felicitated last week spoke about all-inclusive public education for all

The Goan Network
Published Aug 17, 2018, 8:06 PM IST
SHARE ON

After being recognised by government of Maharashtra in Mumbai last week for being awarded the Ramon Magsaysay, education reformer and innovator Sonam Wangchuk spoke about a need for better and all-inclusive public education system for all. Wangchuk is acknowledged the world-over for uniquely systematic, collaborative and community-driven reform of learning systems in Ladakh. The felicities speaker stressed on the need for better and uniform public educational system in India…

READ MORE
Home HOME News GOA NEWS Global GLOBAL GOENKAR Search SEARCH