The Supreme Court of India bench led by Chief Justice of India Justice Surya Kant witnessed drama and a heated exchange of words after a lawyer lashed out at the Chief Justice of India over what appears to be a personal matter, that he was unhappy it wasn’t being taken up for listing despite reminders.
“No, I won’t wait. You can’t sit in that chair, you don’t deserve [it]. You don’t have the integrity for that,” he said apparently in frustration before he was escorted out and now likely faces contempt proceedings.
No doubt it is not the first time an incident of this nature has occurred. In October last year, a 71-year-old advocate Rakesh Kishore hurled a shoe at then Chief Justice B R Gavai apparently being upset over remarks Justice Gavai had made during a plea on the Khajuraho temple. This year in July too similar remarks have been made against the Chief Justice of India, although contempt proceedings were not initiated against the alleged accused.
Incidents like these point to a broader pattern of increasingly vocal criticism targeting the judiciary. Not all the criticism is personal and targeted, but voices questioning the effectiveness, neutrality and the role being played by the judiciary in the decline of India’s democracy are increasingly being expressed, not just on social media, but also in the mainstream media and notably by current and former judges themselves.
On one hand, one recognises that judges and their judgements need to be respected, the same way we expect ‘sporting behaviour’ from players even if a referee or umpire makes a mistake. However, on the other hand, there's increasing evidence that public confidence in the judiciary is waning. Instead of being a resort to which the common people can turn to when justice isn’t available elsewhere, justice from courts has become the exception rather than the norm.
More often than not, the Courts have shown undue deference to the government of the day and granted the government unnecessary concessions on several key issues, including the Election Commission of India’s unauthorised changes to the SIR process.
If the judiciary is serious about not being criticised it first needs to fix itself and make itself more accountable. High Court orders that exempt judicial officers and lawyers from otherwise strict vehicle restrictions during days of poor air quality don’t really help in that regard. Besides who can forget how a previous Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi when faced with a complaint of sexual harassment simply heard his own case, declared that he was innocent and the complaint motivated, and had himself exonerated, but a full court hearing consisting largely of men, no less.
Litigants have to wait months to even get a hearing and cases can drag on for a lifetime. Yet it is people who look up to these judges as a court of last resort in the hope that not only will they get justice, but final justice. As noted Advocate Indira Jaising said: “If the fountain of justice is polluted at its source, where do we go for justice?”
