Criminal action sought, alleging garbage management failures contributed to tragedy

Mahesh Rane and Jitesh Kamat of Together for Mapusa submit a complaint to Mapusa PI Navin Desai on Tuesday. Vijay Bhike is also seen.
MAPUSA
Mounting pressure is building on the Mapusa Municipal Council (MMC) as two separate complaints have been filed with the Mapusa Police alleging that persistent failures in the town's garbage management system contributed to the circumstances that culminated in the death of 22-year-old Samuel Braganza of Gaunsavaddo.
Civil society group Together for Mapusa (TFM) and social worker Sanjay Barde have independently approached the police seeking criminal action against senior municipal officials, arguing that prolonged civic negligence created the conditions that led to the tragedy.
In its complaint, signed by TFM President Mahesh Rane and General Secretary Jitesh Kamat, TFM sought registration of an FIR against the MMC Administrator for alleged abetment of suicide and other offences.
The organisation contended that despite repeated public complaints, authorities failed to address the garbage crisis, resulting in unsanitary conditions, neighbourhood disputes, mental distress and growing tensions among residents.
The group argued that the chain of events leading to Samuel's death stemmed from a garbage-related dispute and alleged that the administration's continued inaction deprived citizens of their constitutional right to live in a clean and healthy environment under Article 21.
"The death of a young citizen cannot be treated as an isolated incident when it is linked to continued administrative failure," TFM stated in its complaint, while demanding seizure of municipal records and a comprehensive investigation into the role of civic authorities.
Speaking after submitting the complaint, TFM President Mahesh Rane said the organisation believes accountability cannot stop with individuals directly involved in the incident.
"When an entire system fails over a prolonged period and repeated complaints go unaddressed, responsibility must also be examined at the administrative level. We have requested the police to investigate whether the continued failure to address the garbage crisis created circumstances that contributed to this tragedy," Rane said.
In a separate representation, social worker Sanjay Barde sought action against the MMC Chief Officer, questioning whether adequate systems exist for the disposal and management of garbage collected from households despite residents paying taxes for waste collection services.
Barde alleged that shortcomings in the municipality's waste management system had adversely affected residents and contributed to tensions within local communities.
He urged police to register an FIR against the Chief Officer, claiming that the failure to provide an effective house-to-house garbage collection mechanism ultimately led to circumstances that cost Samuel his life.
The twin complaints mark an escalation in public demands for accountability following Samuel Braganza's death, which has triggered protests, candlelight vigils and widespread outrage across Mapusa.
While police have received both complaints, it remains unclear whether an FIR will be registered against any municipal officials.