Header
THURSDAY, 18 JUNE 2026
Ticker

Civic duty or public shaming?

Alwyn Fernandes, Benaulim
Published Jun 9
SHARE ON

Recent tragic suicide of a 22-year-old has regrettably shifted from a police investigation to a public trial. While candle-light marches and political backing often characterise such situations, we must wait for the facts. Assumptions create distractions and lead to emotional exhaustion. Crucial questions surrounding the youth’s death remain unanswered. First, is the suicide genuinely connected to the garbage-related video? Second, how did a 22-year-old access a firearm? The family and the press should clarify whether there was a valid licence. Furthermore, garbage dumping is a severe problem in Goa, and authorities cannot be blamed for everything.  

The recent “name and shame” approach has been used by concerned citizens to combat this menace, yet those who report offenders are unfairly branded as villains. In my vaddo of 16 houses, the local Panchayat has assigned a door-to-door garbage collection agency. In my four years of residence, they have never failed to arrive. Yet only four houses consistently hand over their segregated dry waste. What about the other 12 houses that refuse to comply despite the administration’s efforts? My own neighbour frequently dumps plastic bottles nearby. After requesting them to stop, my wife and I often end up cleaning the area and packing their dry waste for the collection agent. If I use the “name and shame” approach to correct a neighbour who refuses to follow basic civic duties, does that really make me the villain?  


Recommended Stories

Alwyn Fernandes, Benaulim
Published Jun 9
SHARE ON

Who qualifies as a Goan?

Arwin Mesquita, Colva
Published Jun 9
SHARE ON

CM Pramod Sawant recently stated that the Mhaje Ghar scheme is meant for Goans. I would like to ask the CM what definition of a ‘Goan’ is being used for this purpose. In my view, any such definition should be clearly explained and, if necessary, linked to long-standing ancestral roots in Goa. There are also concerns about extending benefits to people who have occupied land illegally or constructed houses on government or comunidade land. Any housing scheme should operate…

Read more
Home HOME News GOA NEWS Global GLOBAL GOENKAR Search SEARCH
The Goan Footer