Goa’s outgoing Lokayukta Justice (Retired) P K Misra on Monday left the State for his native home in Odisha after completing his term. Earlier, in an exclusive interview with Prudent Television, he laments that the Goa Lokayukta Act is completely toothless and lacks power to implement the orders of the Lokayukta.
Q: Why do you say the Goa Lokayukta Act is toothless and that it lacks power?
Justice P K Misra: In Kerala and Karnataka, the Lokayukta has been given the power of prosecution, whereas in Goa, the Anti-corruption Bureau (ACB) or the officer in charge of the Police Station has the power to prosecute. There should be power to implement the order of Lokayukta and if the order is not carried out then, the contempt proceedings should be allowed.
Q: Can you elaborate on DA cases against Babu Kavlekar and Pandurang Madkaikar?
As far as Madkaikar is concerned, my focus was on why ACB had not filed FIR against him. I have not made any investigation regarding his case. I had with me only two constables and two head constables as part of my investigative staff. So, it was impossible carry out any investigation. In Kavlekar’s case, the matter is still pending and has to be looked into by the next Lokayukta.
Q: What would you like to say on the govt’s reaction on Action Taken Report?
Action Taken Report has to be given within three months. Under the Goa Lokayukta, it does not mention anything regarding extension. The rejection of the report from the Chief Minister’s and the Governor’s office came within three months whereas the Chief Secretary’s report did not come within that period.
Q: Many of your stinging reports were rejected by the government.
Yes, the government has rejected many of my recommendations. If the Lokayukta’s recommendations are rejected he has the right under Section 60, to make a special report to the Governor which I have done. I expected that such special reports would be placed before the State Assembly under Section 64, but that did not happen. Not a single report has been placed before the Assembly.
Q: How was the Goa govt’s attitude towards the Lokayukta?
Most non-co-operative. The government has the power to make a reference to the Lokayukta under the Section 9 of the Act. They had made the references in three-four cases. But they did not do any follow up by way of appointing any nodal officers to look into the matter.
Q: What about the support system to the Lokayukta office to carry out any investigation?
The less said the better. There were four police personnel and two clerks. There was a retired person as a court officer and a retired person as registrar of the institution. The secretary was also a retired person and was in charge of another department too. There was also an under-secretary who also had additional charges. There was a retired person in the accounts section too. The steno or private secretary is also a retired person. There was a shortage of space too for the office. I was grateful to those people. They were very co-operative.
Q: Your security cover was removed immediately.
That’s a minor thing, blown out of proportion. Personally, I never required any security.
Q: What is your opinion about the Goa government?
Wherever in the country, the State governance is always below the expected level. Goa is not an exception.
Q: What is your message to the people of Goa?
I am grateful to the people of Goa. They are very affectionate and friendly. Goa is a beautiful and healthy place. During my tenure in Goa I never had any major health issues.
