PANAJI
The High Court of Bombay at Goa has directed the State government to give full monetary benefits from January 1, 2001, to 12 police personnel from the CID Dog Unit in Altinho, Panaji, who were denied retrospective pay parity for over two decades.
A Division Bench of Justice Bharati Dangre and Justice Ashish Chavan allowed the writ petition filed by dog handlers holding the ranks of Assistant Sub-Inspector and Head Constable. They had challenged the State’s decision to grant them a higher pay scale only from January 22, 2014.
“The monetary benefits available to the petitioners shall be granted from January 1, 2001, and necessary adjustments shall be made in the benefits conferred on them from January 22, 2014,” the order stated.
The Bench directed the State to calculate the benefits due within 12 weeks and release any arrears owed to the petitioners within six weeks thereafter.
The petitioners argued that they belonged to the same cadre as other Head Constables in the police department, including those in the executive and driver categories. They said that although they performed similar duties, the dog unit personnel were unfairly denied equal benefits for years.
Rejecting the State’s argument, the Court ruled that the petitioners were entitled to the same pay scale and benefits as others in the same cadre.
Referring to a 1993 Supreme Court ruling, the Bench said that financial concerns cannot outweigh constitutional guarantees of equality. It also noted that the government itself had accepted that all Head Constables”whether dog handlers, drivers, or executive”performed similar duties under one rank.
